Name of student | |
Name of assessor(s) | |
Unit/task | |
Asssessment result | |
Assessor's feedback* | |
Date | |
Assessor's signature | |
Print this form to fill it in. * Assessor's feedback. Comment on what was done very well, not so well, and the nature of any deficiency, etc. |
Ross Woods, rev. 2018
Topic |
❏ The title reflects the subject of the paper and is not too long. ❏ The problem is clear, important, and new. ❏ The purpose of the paper (what is to be proven) is clear. ❏ The whole essay is on a single topic and has been narrowed down. |
Introduction |
❏ The essay has an introduction. ❏ The assumptions are clear. ❏ Definitions are clear, including any special terminology. |
Structure |
❏ The outline is easy to understand and follow. ❏ The section titles are used correctly. They are are not too long and accurately reflect the contents of each section. ❏ The logic is acceptable. ❏ Terms are used consistently. ❏ Each section is clearly related to the conclusion. ❏ No elements are repeated unnecessarily. ❏ The outline does not lack any elements that are necessary to reaching the conclusion. ❏ Important aspects are discussed in full while less important aspects are discussed more briefly. ❏ There are no useless details. |
Use of sources |
❏ Sources are good quality and are sufficient to support conclusions. ❏ Data is well selected; all data is relevent and fits the topic. ❏ Facts are reported correctly. ❏ Material is well selected for direct quotation. ❏ Data is analyzed or assessed appropriately. ❏ Data is interpreted in relation to the conclusion. ❏ Writing is objective. ❏ Any generalizations are qualified, they do not overgeneralize. |
Conclusion |
❏ The concluding section has a clear, focused conclusion that resolves the original problem, and shows clearly that the essay has reached its destination. ❏ There is only one main conclusion. ❏ The conclusion is well-supported. |
Language |
❏ Grammar is correct. ❏ The language is clear. ❏ Expression is concise. ❏ Sentences do not unnecessarily repeat elements. ❏ Sentences are not too long or complex. ❏ Spelling is correct and consistent. ❏ Terminology is selected correctly. ❏ The length of sentences varies. ❏ There is no flowery language. ❏ Language is not convoluted. The direction of thought does not turn in the middle of a sentence. ❏ What is written represents the writer’s intent. |
Typing |
❏ Typing is neat and consistent. ❏ Typing follows instructions, including title page and bibliography. ❏ Punctuation is correct. ❏ Quotes are typed correctly. |
References |
❏ Quotes are copied correctly. ❏ References are complete and there is no plagiarism. ❏ The contents of the bibliography are correct. |